| MINNEAPOLIS--Sept. 28, 1999--Citing
continuing losses by Internet travel agencies, the head of the country's
largest travel agency franchiser questioned the future viability of
Internet travel booking sites that are not backed up by "bricks and
mortar" locations. Michael Batt, President of Carlson Wagonlit
Travel's Associate (franchise) division, told 1,000 Carlson Wagonlit
Travel associates that Internet companies are averaging a loss of around
$20 per ticket sold.
Batt made the remarks while introducing Carlson Wagonlit's new
Website, CarlsonTravel.com (www.carlsontravel.com), as part of its
"Click, Walk, Talk" travel strategy at the Carlson Wagonlit
Travel Associate Division's annual meeting in New Orleans.
Can Internet Travel Companies Survive?
"'Pay no attention to the man behind the curtain,' was what the
'Wizard' of Oz sought to tell Dorothy and friends when trying to make
them believe in fantasy," stated Batt. "Similarly, despite
incredible losses experienced on the sale of each ticket and incredibly
low commissions provided for each ticket, Internet vendors would still
have us believe in the fantasy that they are something that they are not
and never will be."
Batt based his comments on a recent review of Internet travel agency
company results. He noted that it is difficult to build and maintain a
high-tech, high-investment business when the funding comes from airline
commission now as low as 4% and hotel groups who are refusing to pay
commission or capping commissions at $2 per stay.
Batt said, "There is a huge amount of lookers, but most bookers
still prefer the service and price competitiveness of professional,
technology-enabled travel agents." Batt stated that the best use of
the Internet business model is in combination with a retail presence,
which is the strategy being pursued by Carlson Wagonlit.
Numerous Studies Point Out Problems In Online
Agency Market
Quoting a study by Boston Consulting, which was reported by The
Financial Times, 62% of every dollar spent by U.S. Web shoppers is going
to bricks and mortar retailers that have on-line operations. The study
revealed that Internet companies are spending an average of $42 to snare
each customer, while "bricks and bytes" retailers (those with
stores and Web presence) spend only $22 per customer.
Another study, conducted by NPD Online Research, revealed that 56% of
on-line travelers reported having completed reservations with a
traditional travel agent after visiting a travel-related site.
"There's a reason why the bricks-and-mortar travel agency will
remain viable," noted Batt. "They are here to stay because
consumers invariably seek out the advice of a real-live human, and they
seek the reassurance and expertise that only professional travel agents
can offer."
Batt cited a third report, released by Forrester Research, which
examined 34 travel-related sites and ranked how well each site converts
its experienced bookers, its visitors' average spending, and what
percentage of their travel they actually book on-line. Forrester noted
that the biggest losers in the fight for the on-line travel market are
cyber-travel agencies. The report states flatly that "on-line
agencies are in peril."
Batt noted that prognosticators who think the travel agency industry
is doomed may be missing the boat (or plane). He noted that the travel
agency industry has had a compounded average growth rate of 6% and sales
of $140 billion in 1999, up from $103 billion in 1995.
Carlson Wagonlit's Click, Walk and Talk
Strategy Unveiled
Based on these findings, Carlson Wagonlit Travel is advancing its
"Click, Walk, Talk" strategy. The comprehensive business
strategy embraces all forms of booking. It allows consumers to research
travel over the Internet (booking it or referring the reservation to a
local Carlson Wagonlit affiliate who can answer questions and complete
the booking); or walk into an agency location for information or
bookings (choosing one of 1,300 Carlson Wagonlit agencies in the U.S.);
or find a Carlson Wagonlit agent on the phone (locating one through
1-800-CARLSON).
Batt told the assembled agency owners and representatives that
"Whether or not the current generation of Internet operators
succeeds, we'll be serving our clients needs and best interests with
exceptional value and service, through phones, retail stores and the
Internet."
Note to Editors: Carlson Leisure Group, a wholly-owned division of
Minneapolis-based Carlson Companies, Inc., manages leisure and franchise
travel operations worldwide. Carlson Leisure Group companies and brands
include: Carlson Wagonlit Travel Associates and Travel Agents
International; Neiman Marcus Travel Services; and Carlson Destination
Marketing Services. Carlson Leisure Group also owns a 22% share of
London-based Thomas Cook. In 1999, for the third consecutive year, the
Carlson Wagonlit Travel Associate program was named the top travel
business franchise by Entrepreneur magazine and the sixth best
franchiser by Franchise Times.
Carlson Wagonlit Travel, Minneapolis
Steve Loucks/Gretchen Kreske
(612) 212-2267
(612) 212-2683
This material is reproduced here by
permission of Carlson Wagonlit Travel |